To say that I didn't like the musical output of the horrors would be a massive understatement...
For me their faux-angst neo-goth theatrics, smacked of style over substance every time I saw them play. I felt like I was the only one seeing right through the facade of big hair, eye makeup and sharp tailoring, right to what lay at the heart of the phenomenon: Art-School, schlock-horror panto. A horrors gig always felt like an experience more akin to seeing a mainstream manufactured pop act, (with act being the operative word). It was all smoke and mirrors, and ways of keeping as much artifice as possible between the fans and the music. A philosophy of "Keep em' deaf, keep em' dazed, but above all never let them work out we haven't actually got any songs".
They tried so hard to be dark, gothic, and gloomy, that they created a kind of "fake dark" that was no more authentic than the "fake sexy" of Girls Aloud or the "fake pop/punk"of McFly. But all this without any of the wit, and charm of either of those bands. If you're going to not have soaring melody, you need a pretty amazing rhythm section. If you don't want a rhythm section you're lyrics will have to be particularly witty/catchy/clever. If you don't intend on writing brilliant lyrics you'll definitely need some strings some horns, some vocal hooks, something, anything. Or if you don't fancy any of the above, you could just write the Horrors first album.
I'm glad that I can finally write what I think about their first effort (without being seen as an opportunist mudslinger) as my opinions on their music have turned a tide upon hearing some of their second album.
It appears the lads in black have woken up and smelt the musical coffee. Faris Rotter sings, real melodies, real tunes. They utilise their musical skill (which was always apparent, just misappropriated) to create genuinely atmospheric, memorable songs. It feels like they finally have their ingredients in the right order. They are no longer trying to bake a cake using three sardines, pineapple juice and a wheel of brie. Sponge, check, icing, check! So far their sound is finely crafted, and ermm moreish. And I never thought I'd say that after listening to an 8 minute Horrors track.
Well done
Rack the Jipper